03
Tue, Dec
29 New Articles

Cartel Law – Records and Data of Your Telecommunication Traffic Now as Evidence

Cartel Law – Records and Data of Your Telecommunication Traffic Now as Evidence

Czech Republic
Tools
Typography
  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

The content of communications recorded by criminal law enforcement authorities (LEAs) and traffic and location data; Not only voice communications, but also electronic messages made not only from a mobile phone, but also from landlines and other devices; Records of surveillance of persons and property by the LEAs. This and other information have so far reached the Czech national competition authority (Czech NCA) without being able to use it legally as evidence in the proceedings.

A major amendment to the Czech Republic Act on Protection of Competition(ZOHS) now allows the Czech NCA to use these records and data from the LEAs as evidence "in the exercise of supervision in the case of a secret horizontal agreement or concerted practice, which has as its object the distortion of competition".

The Czech NCA cannot therefore use the records in all kinds of proceedings. Typically, these will be used in the proceedings concerning prohibited agreements between the participants in tender procedures (bid-rigging), or other prohibited agreements between competitors (cartels).

Likewise, not all criminal proceedings qualify as a source of such records and data.

These must have been:

  1. taken by the LEA in criminal proceedings involving natural persons for a crime under Section 248(2) of the Czech Criminal Code (breach of regulations on rules of economic competition) and subsequently handed over to the Czech NCA after the end of the pre-trial proceedings, or
  2. taken in criminal proceedings for any of the other crimes against mandatory rules of market economy and circulation of goods in dealing with foreign countries (typically, e.g., machinations in commission of public contract and public contest), if the LEA has referred or handed over the case to the Czech NCA.

Only records and data taken after 29 July 2023 and only in Czech NCA proceedings initiated after the said date may be used as evidence.

Despite these limitations and safeguards, this is undoubtedly the most controversial amendment introduced by this major amendment to the ZOHS. In its current form, it is potentially contradictory to the right to defence and some other fundamental rights and freedoms.

We will bring you an overview of the remaining relevant amendments in the future. Stay tuned!

By Michal Hrabovsky, Head of Competition, Eversheds Sutherland

Eversheds Sutherland at a Glance

Eversheds Sutherland with offices in Bratislava and Prague and as part of an international network, provides comprehensive legal advice also in foreign jurisdictions.

Our team consists of a total of more than 40 lawyers in the Czech Republic and Slovakia, most of whom have previously worked at major international and local law firms and have extensive experience in particular in the areas of corporate law, including mergers and acquisitions, capital markets, real estate, employment law, competition law, litigation and arbitration, energy, infrastructure, as well as environmental and ESG law.

Our advisory services are offered in Slovak, German, Czech and English language. Members of our team include attorneys registered with the Austrian Bar Association. On this basis, and because we are part of Eversheds Sutherland, we are also able to offer extensive legal support on various foreign legal issues.

We listen to our clients, we understand their business and we also understand what they need. So we can always find the best solution for the particular situation. We work quickly, efficiently and take responsibility for our work.

Firm's website.